Peak Oil, Sustainabilty, and the future of capitalism.
I'm tired of people ignoring peak oil. Just like they ignored the ozone hole. Just like people who need proof that a specific atmospheric event is a direct result of global warming before they will admit that tinkering with the biosphere might not be such a great idea after all.
Even those who are ready to admit peak oil might be coming some day, maybe even soon, fail to grasp just how historic an "event" it really is. They say "worst case is a resource war, best case is more resources devoted to alternative energy."
Bullshit. First of all the worst case scenario for peak oil is not just resource war, it is total economic collapse, if not total ecological collapse. It is stone-age technology trying to sustain information-age populations. It is nine dead bodies for every human still breathing. And that's just the beginning, if climate and enviornmental changes already irreversably underway interact with normal stochastic environmental variablity in just the wrong way - it is quite literaly the end of the world for we poor humans, game over, roaches win. Think I'm exagerating? Do you know where our oxygen comes from? Do you know how resilient our species would be without the technological infrastructure that supports basically every human activity experienced by anybody who actually has access to blogs? Ask an Inuit, or a Bushman living in the traditional manner, how fragile human existence is, you might get a decent answer, but ask me? ask you? our lives are so mediated by technology that we cannot begin to imagine life without it. But why bother when it's here to stay? You might ask. Because it just isn't, is the unfortunate answer. Sure there are paths throught the coming crisis that leave our civilization intact, but what if the transportation and communications infrastructure collapses. Do you know how to treat smallpox, how to repair an electrical substation, how to build a computer out of gold and sand? It's not one event that collapses societies, it's a cascade failure, like dominoes, one system goes down because of it's position relative to another. None of it is inevitable, and none of it is pre-ordained, but none of it is invulnerable either. Have you read 1984? That's as good a guess as any as to what power will do to preserve itself - but what happens when the bioshpere cannot support the demands of the oligarchy, does the oligarchy admit defeat and try for an orderly retreat? Or does it protect its own for as long as possible, damning its survivors to increasingly bleak and destitute circumstances in a vain attempt to preserve power and privilege to the last possible moment? The latter, of course, but does the mere position of influence guarantee success in such an insane, and life-defeating endeavour? Not at all. But to expect any less from the elite times of crisis is to close ones eyes to the brutal realities of human nature. So the downside of peak oil isn't just WWIII, it's a sad tale of self-destruction ushered in by the futile attempts of the privileged to hold on to their privilege.
On the other hand, the plus side to peak oil isn't just more corporate money diverted to Hybrid-electric SUVs. It heralds the possiblity for an end to the ultimate hubris of civilization. We stand at the threshold of redemption. For the first time since, for those of you who appreciate the parable, Eve ate the apple, we are at the same time wise enough to see the folly of our supposed "dominion" over nature, powerful enough to secure for ourselves a privileged, yet sustainable place at the apex of the food chain (or something equally comfortable) and lucky enough to have achieved this knowlege before the bioshpere is simply too exhausted to support our hubris any longer.
So, you see, Peak Oil is both the death knell of 4000 years of koyaanisqatsi, and the glorious peal of the trumpets heralding a real new age. And not the pathetic, parasitic, fawning hypocrasy of the California New Age movement, but the underlying promise of real wisdom which motivated so many of those well-meaning, but woefully mis-informed cobblers and tinkers with foreign ideologies they didn't understand - I'm talking about a real birth of real understanding that doesn't just pretend to the wisdom of another culture without comprehension, but evolves of necessity from all cultures, in all places out of the inescapable collapse of the dominant paradigm. There are a great many smart people in this world, and all of them have unprecedented access to the lessons of all of humanities recorded failures, and their successes. We have, on the one hand, the church of science whose faith is repeatability and whose mantra is "prove it," and on the other hand, the entirety of human spiritual development which has cross-fertilized and co-evolved to the point where a man the likes of Joeseph Cambell can see the common threads which weave through the entire tapestry of human spirituality, revealing at a most fundimental level what it means to be human, and what humans mean by "fundimental." How, in this unparalleled atmosphere of fertility and possibility and wisdom, can the Jingoistic, Nationalistic, Racist voices of ignorance and aggression stifle the patently obvious conclusion that we all matter, that we all have something to contribute to the story of humanity, and the story of life itself.
Ok, so maybe we'll all just kill each other... But maybe we won't, and if we don't, there has never, in the history of the world, been a better opportunity for humanity as a whole, to learn from all the mistakes of all of the rest of humanity as a whole. So I say, let's get learning, and let's bid good riddance to the era of cheap oil, cheap philosophy, cheap relationships, cheap politicians, and cheap society.
Corporations aren't people, and profit is a means, not a end. A person's value is measured by their contribution to their community, not by their ability to extract wealth from it. Let conspicuous consumption be reviled as the anathema to sustainable comunity. Let service again be the measure by which we judge a person's worth in society (if indeed it ever was, let it be again, and if it wasn't, let us make the myth of yesterday, the guiding principle of tomorrow).
Damn it I am PROUD of my heritage, even if I am not proud of my administration. America was founded on principle like "All men-and we are smart enough to read humans here by now, aren't we?- are created equal" and I feel it is a very telling point that the argument over property versus happiness was decided in the favor of all of us being guaranteed the rights of "life, liberty and the persuit of happiness." That is the battle which was won that day, and which we fight again today - should we confuse the pursuit of property with the pursuit of happiness? NO! Not then, not now, not tomorrow. Let it be we Americans who embrace the post-peak economy and show the world how to be rich in real terms, instead of the hopelessly impoverished terms of the soulless capitalist.
Jefferson knew, even as a slaveholder, that holding slaves emperiled the soul - let us be so wise as to know, even as captialists, that holding capital and deeming it valuable is no less perilous because it blinds us to what is truly valuable. Communism is failed and dead, captialism must now be recognized as an equally failed expiriment. What is to succeed it? I don't know, but words like "sustainability," "community," and "humility" are sure to describe it if it actually works.
Even those who are ready to admit peak oil might be coming some day, maybe even soon, fail to grasp just how historic an "event" it really is. They say "worst case is a resource war, best case is more resources devoted to alternative energy."
Bullshit. First of all the worst case scenario for peak oil is not just resource war, it is total economic collapse, if not total ecological collapse. It is stone-age technology trying to sustain information-age populations. It is nine dead bodies for every human still breathing. And that's just the beginning, if climate and enviornmental changes already irreversably underway interact with normal stochastic environmental variablity in just the wrong way - it is quite literaly the end of the world for we poor humans, game over, roaches win. Think I'm exagerating? Do you know where our oxygen comes from? Do you know how resilient our species would be without the technological infrastructure that supports basically every human activity experienced by anybody who actually has access to blogs? Ask an Inuit, or a Bushman living in the traditional manner, how fragile human existence is, you might get a decent answer, but ask me? ask you? our lives are so mediated by technology that we cannot begin to imagine life without it. But why bother when it's here to stay? You might ask. Because it just isn't, is the unfortunate answer. Sure there are paths throught the coming crisis that leave our civilization intact, but what if the transportation and communications infrastructure collapses. Do you know how to treat smallpox, how to repair an electrical substation, how to build a computer out of gold and sand? It's not one event that collapses societies, it's a cascade failure, like dominoes, one system goes down because of it's position relative to another. None of it is inevitable, and none of it is pre-ordained, but none of it is invulnerable either. Have you read 1984? That's as good a guess as any as to what power will do to preserve itself - but what happens when the bioshpere cannot support the demands of the oligarchy, does the oligarchy admit defeat and try for an orderly retreat? Or does it protect its own for as long as possible, damning its survivors to increasingly bleak and destitute circumstances in a vain attempt to preserve power and privilege to the last possible moment? The latter, of course, but does the mere position of influence guarantee success in such an insane, and life-defeating endeavour? Not at all. But to expect any less from the elite times of crisis is to close ones eyes to the brutal realities of human nature. So the downside of peak oil isn't just WWIII, it's a sad tale of self-destruction ushered in by the futile attempts of the privileged to hold on to their privilege.
On the other hand, the plus side to peak oil isn't just more corporate money diverted to Hybrid-electric SUVs. It heralds the possiblity for an end to the ultimate hubris of civilization. We stand at the threshold of redemption. For the first time since, for those of you who appreciate the parable, Eve ate the apple, we are at the same time wise enough to see the folly of our supposed "dominion" over nature, powerful enough to secure for ourselves a privileged, yet sustainable place at the apex of the food chain (or something equally comfortable) and lucky enough to have achieved this knowlege before the bioshpere is simply too exhausted to support our hubris any longer.
So, you see, Peak Oil is both the death knell of 4000 years of koyaanisqatsi, and the glorious peal of the trumpets heralding a real new age. And not the pathetic, parasitic, fawning hypocrasy of the California New Age movement, but the underlying promise of real wisdom which motivated so many of those well-meaning, but woefully mis-informed cobblers and tinkers with foreign ideologies they didn't understand - I'm talking about a real birth of real understanding that doesn't just pretend to the wisdom of another culture without comprehension, but evolves of necessity from all cultures, in all places out of the inescapable collapse of the dominant paradigm. There are a great many smart people in this world, and all of them have unprecedented access to the lessons of all of humanities recorded failures, and their successes. We have, on the one hand, the church of science whose faith is repeatability and whose mantra is "prove it," and on the other hand, the entirety of human spiritual development which has cross-fertilized and co-evolved to the point where a man the likes of Joeseph Cambell can see the common threads which weave through the entire tapestry of human spirituality, revealing at a most fundimental level what it means to be human, and what humans mean by "fundimental." How, in this unparalleled atmosphere of fertility and possibility and wisdom, can the Jingoistic, Nationalistic, Racist voices of ignorance and aggression stifle the patently obvious conclusion that we all matter, that we all have something to contribute to the story of humanity, and the story of life itself.
Ok, so maybe we'll all just kill each other... But maybe we won't, and if we don't, there has never, in the history of the world, been a better opportunity for humanity as a whole, to learn from all the mistakes of all of the rest of humanity as a whole. So I say, let's get learning, and let's bid good riddance to the era of cheap oil, cheap philosophy, cheap relationships, cheap politicians, and cheap society.
Corporations aren't people, and profit is a means, not a end. A person's value is measured by their contribution to their community, not by their ability to extract wealth from it. Let conspicuous consumption be reviled as the anathema to sustainable comunity. Let service again be the measure by which we judge a person's worth in society (if indeed it ever was, let it be again, and if it wasn't, let us make the myth of yesterday, the guiding principle of tomorrow).
Damn it I am PROUD of my heritage, even if I am not proud of my administration. America was founded on principle like "All men-and we are smart enough to read humans here by now, aren't we?- are created equal" and I feel it is a very telling point that the argument over property versus happiness was decided in the favor of all of us being guaranteed the rights of "life, liberty and the persuit of happiness." That is the battle which was won that day, and which we fight again today - should we confuse the pursuit of property with the pursuit of happiness? NO! Not then, not now, not tomorrow. Let it be we Americans who embrace the post-peak economy and show the world how to be rich in real terms, instead of the hopelessly impoverished terms of the soulless capitalist.
Jefferson knew, even as a slaveholder, that holding slaves emperiled the soul - let us be so wise as to know, even as captialists, that holding capital and deeming it valuable is no less perilous because it blinds us to what is truly valuable. Communism is failed and dead, captialism must now be recognized as an equally failed expiriment. What is to succeed it? I don't know, but words like "sustainability," "community," and "humility" are sure to describe it if it actually works.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home